So I haven't posted on this blog for almost a year, but I just finished Yesteryear, and wow! I started it on Saturday night and finished it Tuesday morning before work. This may be the first time ever in life that I have woken up, instantly reached for the book I was reading, and kept making deals with myself like, "You need to start getting ready for work at 6:45. Well, no, you don't have that much left, 7:00 is fine. Oh, crap, it's 7:15," and so on until I was done.
Yesteryear tells the story of Natalie Heller Mills, a tradwife influencer. We learn almost immediately that her life is not what she presents on Instagram; she has two nannies, a producer, and several farmhands that are unseen on camera. Then, one day, she wakes up in 1855; she seems to be living in the same house, but without any electricity, indoor plumbing, modern appliances, etc. Other things are off, as well; back in her previous life, she had five children named Clementine, Stetson, Samuel, Jessa, and Junebug, and a sixth on the way. In 1855, her children are named Mary, Abel, Noah, and Maeve. As she tries to figure out how she got here and what is going on, the book flashes back to her previous life to explain how she got to her "successful tradwife" status and where things all went wrong. In that life, she grew up in a conservative Christian household; went to Harvard on scholarship; met and married Caleb, the wealthy son of a politician; began having children; and decided to, with the financial help of her father-in-law, buy the property that she calls Yesteryear Ranch.
One thing that I thought was incredibly brilliant about the book was that, because the whole thing is told from Natalie's perspective, it takes until about halfway through to realize how completely incompetent Natalie and Caleb are. She realizes that Caleb is very dumb pretty soon into their marriage, but when she describes the early days of starting the ranch, she reveals pretty casually and carelessly that their first dairy cow and flock of chickens die almost immediately. "Oh," I thought in surprise. "They have absolutely no idea what they're doing." Up until this point, I knew they had more help at the ranch than they let on, but I didn't think their whole life was a complete sham.
BIG TIME SPOILERS BELOW!!!!!
It's at this point that I don't think I can talk about this book anymore without giving away the plot twist, so stop reading if you don't want spoilers. We eventually find out that the 1855 sections are not actually taking place in 1855, and that Natalie suffered a complete mental breakdown after her producer, Shannon, exposed her as a fraud. At that point, she and Caleb decided they would strip their home of all modern amenities and live the "traditional" lifestyle for real. Eventually, Clementine (by then a teenager) decided to help Stetson, Samuel, Jessa, and Junebug escape and live with their grandmother. Mary was the baby that Natalie was pregnant with at the time she was exposed as a fraud; she and Caleb went on to have Abel, Noah, and Maeve. Clementine eventually turns back up to rescue the remaining children.
I have heard that a lot of people really did not like this twist. I think it actually made a lot of sense. I kind of figured all along that they weren't really in 1855, because Natalie still had all of her old memories of her previous life, and there was nothing to suggest time travel or any other sort of sci-fi/fantasy element. My theory the whole time was that Caleb and her politician father-in-law were setting her up/making her think that she was crazy somehow/for some reason. I didn't think she actually *was* crazy, but looking back, there were signs that she was headed that way and that it wasn't *that* farfetched for her to go down this path. There is discussion of how, when she and Caleb bought Yesteryear, they renovated it to make it look more rustic and to put all modern appliances out of view even though it had just recently been updated. Her mother flat-out tells her that she doesn't understand why she would do this and that this worries her.
There are other details that indicate that she is slipping mentally; we learn at one point that she routinely doesn't feed her children dinner until late at night because she is trying too hard to make perfect, elaborate, Instagram-worthy meals. At another point, a fan realizes that Natalie has left her baby in the car while she grocery shopped. At yet another point, Natalie realizes that she has said something that she thought was all in her head out loud, and we realize that maybe she has been doing that a lot. There is also the issue that Caleb is very easily influenced; he falls under the spell of the "manosphere," then at another point believes he is in love with their producer, Shannon, and says that he wants to move to New York with her. It's not hard to believe that he would go along with Natalie's plan to become homesteaders for real. My only real issue is that I think there would have been more signs that they were living in contemporary times. At one point, 1855 Natalie finds a piece of a microphone; I think there would have been other things like that. Once all of their employees were no longer helping, I just don't think she and Caleb would have done that competent of a job of stripping their home of its modern amenities. I would have liked to see Natalie slowly noticing more details that tipped her off to what was really going on.
And, once the twist is revealed, things just get more disturbing the more that you think about them. The day after I read it, I thought, "they really just kept having more kids and neglecting them. Clementine really had to come back and rescue a whole second set of kids." It is also mentioned that every time a dairy cow would die, they would get another and give it the same name, Sassafrass, so there was also just a total disregard for animals. So many things that were just so messed up.
My only other issue was that, because the entire story is from Natalie's perspective, we really only see the reality of things when she inadvertently reveals something that she doesn't realize is damning or when another character overtly calls her out on something. Because of that, some details are unclear. For example, prior to Shannon exposing Natalie as a fraud, Natalie assaults Shannon. The way that Shannon describes it in a television interview is different from the way that Natalie describes and seems to remember it. I was inclined to believe Shannon, but I listened to one podcast where the hosts seemed to think Shannon was lying and another that just felt it was unclear what happened. I think those moments of unclarity were just the way they had to be because of how the story was told, but I still wanted to know more.
As a whole, though, I really liked it. So much to talk about, and so much I haven't even touched on here. I'll be thinking about it for a long time.













